The European Union cannot proclaim itself into credibility: Opinion

The EU house has a tidy facade but behind the scenes things are much more messy
The EU is good at keeping up appearances
Source: Global South World/ ChatGPT
Most Read

The European Union has a credibility problem, and, regrettably, one of its main sources is the very people who speak on its behalf. Listen to the leaders in Brussels and you often get the impression of a united Europe, with a shared vision on the great international questions and a political will equal to its economic weight. Look at what the leaders of the member states actually say, and a rather different reality emerges, one in which national interests claim, ever more insistently, the place that official European rhetoric sometimes seems determined to deny them.

The European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen's recent visit to Romania offers a good starting point. In Bucharest, she assured Romanians that they can count on a strong, united European response to the threats in the Black Sea. An encouraging statement, no doubt, if we set aside the growing difficulty Europeans have in agreeing on how to support Ukraine.

Almost at the same moment, Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico reaffirmed his country's refusal to take part in a new European loan for Ukraine. He branded as blackmail German Chancellor Friedrich Merz's plan to make approval of the Union's next multiannual budget conditional on every member state contributing to Kyiv's financing.

For his part, Hungarian Prime Minister Péter Magyar rejected linking the two issues, citing, among other things, his own country's budget difficulties. It is worth noting that we are no longer talking about Viktor Orbán, whose departure from the leadership of Hungary many in Brussels saw as a chance to restore European unity. We are talking about his successor, a leader of a different political stripe who, now that he must decide on behalf of his own country, finds that Hungary's interests do not always coincide with the Commission's priorities. And the reservations voiced by the Czech Republic and Bulgaria suggest these are not isolated exceptions.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Children on migrant dinghy(1)

Migrants crowd onto dinghy in France as tensions flare during Channel crossing

We are not debating here whether these leaders are right, or whether supporting Ukraine is necessary or wise. The point is the gap between the unity proclaimed in Brussels and the unity that actually exists.

The European Union is a political construct made up of sovereign states, each with its own interests, vulnerabilities and priorities, and these are not always the same. Disagreement is natural. What should worry us far more is the tendency of the European leadership to gloss over it in public: to present as consensus what is still being negotiated, and as collective will what is sometimes merely the position of a majority.

The picture of a united Europe grows even less convincing when, lacking arguments strong enough to produce consensus, Brussels reaches for financial conditions to manufacture it.

From Europe to the Rest of the World

If the European Union struggles to speak for its own members, it becomes even harder to justify the ease with which its representatives sometimes assume the role of interpreters for other states, or even for entire continents. Also in Bucharest, Ursula von der Leyen stressed the importance of freedom of navigation in the Black Sea for Europe's economy, for Ukraine and for global food security. She reminded her audience that millions of people depend on food shipments along this route, many of them in Africa.

She is right. The war in Ukraine and the disruption of maritime transport have shaken international grain markets, pushed prices up and deepened the food insecurity of several African states. But there is a question that European rhetoric seems keen to avoid: why do so many African countries, whose populations feel the consequences of the war, refuse to join the West in its efforts to isolate Russia? Why do some even strengthen their ties with Moscow?

In the UN General Assembly vote of 2 March 2022, only 28 of Africa's 54 states backed the resolution condemning Russian aggression. The rest abstained or did not vote, and Eritrea voted against. Moreover, even for the states that did condemn the aggression, this did not automatically mean embracing the Western policy of sanctioning and isolating Moscow. And African positions have not shifted in any meaningful way from 2022 to today.

Are we to understand that African leaders know less than European leaders about the situation of their own people? That they are unaware of the food shortages those people face? Or, quite simply, that they weigh the situation, their responsibilities and above all their own interests differently?

Russia is itself a major supplier of grain and fertilizer to many African countries, and for some of them the relationship with Moscow has an important military and security dimension. Others refuse, on principle or out of strategic calculation, to side with either camp in a confrontation they do not see as theirs. Besides, Africa's food problems did not begin with the invasion of Ukraine. They have far more complex causes, from local conflicts and political instability to poverty, drought and deep structural economic weaknesses.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Indonesia wiretapping

Indonesia rocked by presidential spying scandal

None of this absolves Russia of responsibility for starting the war, nor does it diminish the gravity of its consequences. But it forces us to accept that the African view of the conflict may differ from the European one, and that African states have the right to define their own interests, even when their conclusions do not suit Brussels.

Credibility Cannot Be Proclaimed

The problem with the European Union is not that it promotes certain values, supports Ukraine or draws attention to the global consequences of the war. It is that its representatives sometimes seem to mistake their own convictions for a European consensus, and their own assessments for universally accepted political truths.

Yet when you speak of Europe's unity while member states publicly clash over fundamental decisions, you damage your credibility. And when you invoke the interests of other peoples without paying enough attention to how they define those interests themselves, you severely limit your ability to persuade them. From there, it is only a short step to turning dialogue into a lecture and negotiation into an exercise in compliance.

The European Union still commands impressive economic resources, considerable influence and a political potential few international actors can match. But none of this automatically becomes authority and credibility. An institution's credibility depends, to a decisive degree, on the credibility of those who represent it: on their ability to grasp reality, to recognize the limits of their mandate, and to build consensus rather than merely proclaim it.

Europe needs leaders who can turn the diversity of national interests into a common strength instead of replacing it with a declarative unanimity. It needs leaders who persuade rather than coerce, and who understand that respecting the interests of others is a condition of having one's own respected. Because before it claims to speak in the name of the world, the European Union should prove that it can speak, credibly, in the name of Europe.

Silviu Predoiu is a former Romanian intelligence official and presidential candidate. The opinions expressed in this article are his own and do not represent Global South World.